Discussions this morning and a thought last night brought an ongoing dilemma back up. It’s an ongoing discussion; but not one that I have constantly with another person. It’s a discussion that takes place in my mind.
Oh, the wisdom that pours out of me when driving down the road or in the shower.
There is a tendency in religion to follow the pendulum shift. All too often our idea of who God is and what He can or cannot do is based not on deep theological discussion or intimate prayer; but it is determined as a response to another way of thinking or belief or action. One takes a scripture or inspiration from God and begins to build a ministry upon that one thought. They take it to the extreme; and another then looks at the extreme and determines that it is wrong and then seeks to counteract that belief by taking their beliefs to the opposite extreme. It is a pendulum shift. It is honestly how most of our idea of who God is and how we believe came about… as a response to a perceived error.
This has not been entirely horrible, however, because some of our ideas of God and following God have been really, really bad from a Biblical point of view. These ideas (heresies) needed to be corrected. In time, the corrections were corrected and we come to where we are today.
However, since we have determined our theology from extremes it is all too convenient to see everything in the context of extremes. If I let the record show that I don’t believe a certain way, then all those who believe that certain way have a tendency to think (and even place a label on me) that I believe in whatever the extreme opposite end of that belief is. Examples of this are: Once Saved always Saved vs. Backsliding; Emergent vs. Evangelical; Liberal vs. Conservative; Pentecostal vs. Ecumenical; Republican vs. Democrat; Social Justice vs. Anyone who Wants to Make Little Kids Drink Radioactive Water and Polar Bears Die.
Now, I understand that some could argue with my labels. You could have a valid arguement that I could have used a better term or phrase. To those I say, get over yourself. We’re too hung up on titles as well, but that is the subject of another post (or an underlying secret theme of this one at the least).
There’s the rub. We don’t take time to listen to one another. We spend our time thinking of our argument while the other one is speaking. This creates a tension that serves to divide rather than facilitate the conquering of Jesus Christ over sin in the lives of those we are trying to reach. It also means that we don’t hear the heart of the other person when we are only listening to his/her words and filtering them through our preconceived ideas.
1)The fact is that there are somethings that are true. They are very true, they will always be true, and if you don’t believe them then you are wrong. These things are few. 2) There are other things that are not always true, or have partial truth… but only in the context of the whole and not the specific. The other side of the coin must be seen and applied with these things or there will be dangerous (although unintended) consequences. 3) There are things that are not true. They will never be true, and if you believe them you are wrong. If I don’t believe that they are true, though, it doesn’t automatically mean that I believe the total polar opposite (extreme) is true.
Here’s what I have learned:
- There are some things I will not say or give my opinion on. (This is hard for me, because I am opinionated… just ask my wife.) However, my opinions will not serve to facilitate the greater good in some situations. The person might not be ready to hear them. The person might not need to hear any opinion, but just be listened to. There are times when silence is agreement; but there are more times when silence is just polite.
- There are some times when my opinions will be given partially with dialogue. This is when I see your point, but wonder out loud if you have thought about “this…” These times are healthy, as long as we listen and refuse to label into that opposite extreme. It’s a delicate balancing act, and it’s hard not to come off defensive during these times. It is also important that I am not trying to be “devil’s advocate.” For one, he doesn’t really need an advocate; and for two, this can become enjoyable. You may call it being the voice of reason, but some advice… no one wants to continually be around that person who always says, “But what about…”
- There are some opinions I have that I don’t care what you think. Sorry, but I don’t. First, if I don’t ask… I don’t care. Second, if I tell you I don’t care… believe me. Understand, these times should be VERY few that other’s opinions don’t matter; but perhaps they will be there. These are usually not on important issues, but preferences. I’m working on a PC. I don’t care that you have a Mac or that you think it’s better. I have a Blackberry not an iPhone. I like jeans in the winter and shorts in the summer… meaning you’re not going to see me in a suit a lot. I can’t listen to Bill Gaither much. I am probably going to not answer the phone if my son is up to bat at his baseball game. I love you, but…
- There are some times when my opinions don’t matter. “What do you think, Pastor?” Well, if I don’t know I’m not afraid to say it. In fact, this becomes very frustrating to all those who have to have everything written down. There are times I don’t know (and quite frankly times I don’t care) and I will tell you. However, in these times that I don’t know I lead them to the One who does. God knows all, and quite frankly my opinion on issues in your life that you need a pastor about really don’t matter at all. The Word of God is our source. I may not like what it says and I may try to find the loophole; but in the end His Word is the only thing truly True.
Bottom line is this: don’t hear one thing and assume another. (Seems like someone once told me what happens when you assume, but I’m too Holy to remember it) I have some books that I read because I want to think more or because someone I am trying to make a connection with gave them to me, not because I subscribe to all that writer says or does. I may come from a tradition or race or culture that is different from yours but don’t turn me off. Dialogue with me… listen to me… and I will listen to you.
What can we agree on? That is my focus.
I’ll let God change the things He wants to in you… and in me.